Anna Beachy eagerly begins a new chapter in her life as a Lancaster County tour guide in the picturesque area where her grandmother once stayed. Anna wishes she could talk with her about those long-ago days, but the elderly woman suffers from Alzheimer's. Beyond a vague comment about an old stone wall, much about her grandmother's time there is a mystery.
Anna finds herself unexpectedly befriended by a handsome Mennonite and a young Old Order widower who manages a local horse retreat serving Amish children with special needs. As Anna grows closer to both men, she's faced with a difficult choice--one in potential conflict with the expectations of her parents. Will Anna discover true love and the truth about her grandmother's past or find only heartbreak?